Cardinal Brandmuller Responds to Archbishop Vigano

Please review post

Cardinal Brandmuller’s response to Archbishop Vigano’s call to disregard the Council will leave some people unhappy.

© 2020, Anthony Stine. All rights reserved. You may reuse or copy this post by giving credit and providing a link.

Pages: 1 2


  1. Armando Lagrutta

    I appreciate your courage posting this link to Settimo Cielo with the thoughtful response of Cardinal Brandmuller to the arguments made by Archbishop Vigano. Here is a related commentary by Sandro Magister:
    I have been following this story with some interest, but I am not aligned in any way with the “hermeneutics of rupture”. I keep praying, like Card. Brandmuller that patience and modesty prevail (2 Tim 4: 1- 5).

  2. Steven Cornett

    It’s the typical modernist claptrap that gives orthodox Catholics a that special head (and soul) ache that makes migraines seem like a mere inconvenience.

    Brandmuller seems inordinately proud of the event and their footnotes.

    “See, it’s not a bonfire of tradition! Look at all the footnotes we put in with the fuel and the fuze.”

  3. Michael Dowd

    Vatican II is a catastrophe for the Church it must be abrogated in its entirety. There is no other rational conclusion. Vigano is correct; Brandmuller wrong.


Leave a Reply to Michael Dowd Cancel reply